Decision 1296/2558 (2015): Presumption of Marital Property
The dispute concerned a house built with one spouse’s personal funds before marriage. After the wedding, the couple used the house as their matrimonial home. Upon divorce, the paying spouse claimed it remained personal property. The Supreme Court applied section 1474(3) CCC and reaffirmed that profits, benefits, or increases in value from personal property during marriage are presumed marital unless clearly excluded by law or agreement. In case of doubt, property is presumed to be Sin Somros (marital property).
Practical impact
- Even pre-marital property can generate marital rights if it produces benefits during marriage.
- Clear documentation is essential to keep improvements or gains classified as personal.
- In doubt, courts tend to treat the asset, or its increased value, as subject to division.